Address
F: 519-583-3737 P: 519-583-2929
Port Dover Family Dentistry
Dentist discussing replacement of an old filling with a patient in Port Dover

Port Dover Family Dentistry

Replacement of Old or Stained Fillings in Tillsonburg

Old fillings can crack, leak or look dark. How the dentist decides whether to replace one, and which tooth-coloured choices Tillsonburg patients can consider.

New patients welcomeCDCP accepted

Let’s get you smiling

Book an appointment

Tell us how we can help. Our team will follow up to confirm a time.

By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request.

Tillsonburg patients are welcome at our Port Dover office

Every dental service for Tillsonburg patients

Refreshing older dental work

Not every old filling needs replacing, but some do.

Fillings do not last forever. Over years of chewing, they can wear, crack, pull away from the tooth or develop decay around the edges. Some, particularly older silver or tooth-coloured fillings, may also become stained or noticeably dark. Replacing them can be about tooth health, appearance or both.

Tillsonburg patients can have older fillings assessed at our Port Dover office. If several teeth are involved, asking how replacements could be grouped or sequenced helps balance comfort with the number of trips you need to make.

Talk to our team
Dentist showing an adult patient an educational model of an older dark dental filling

Assessing the filling

Replacement starts with a careful look.

  • Signs a filling may be failing

    Sensitivity, food catching, a rough edge, visible cracks, a dark line around the edge or a change in how the tooth feels when chewing can all suggest a filling needs attention. Some failing fillings cause no symptoms. Mention any changes you have noticed so the dentist knows where to focus.

  • How the dentist evaluates it

    The dentist examines the filling’s edges, checks for cracks and may use X-rays to look for decay beneath it. A filling that is intact and sealed may not need replacing, even if it is old. Ask the dentist to explain whether replacement is needed for health reasons or would be mainly cosmetic.

Making the choice

Understand why replacement is suggested.

Clinical versus cosmetic reasons

Replacing a failing filling protects the tooth from further decay or fracture. Replacing a sound filling purely for appearance is a personal choice, and it does involve removing some tooth structure. The dentist can help you understand the benefits and risks so you can decide what suits you.

Weighing the trade-offs

Each time a filling is replaced, the cavity may become slightly larger. For very large fillings, an onlay or crown might be suggested instead. Ask about the long-term implications for the tooth, particularly if you are considering replacing several fillings at once.

Replacement options

The right material depends on the tooth.

Tooth-coloured composite fillings

Composite resin is a common replacement, offering a tooth-coloured appearance and bonding to the tooth. It suits many small to moderate restorations. The dentist will match the shade to your surrounding teeth. Ask how composite is expected to perform for the specific tooth and bite involved.

Inlays, onlays and crowns

If the old filling is large or the tooth is weakened, a ceramic inlay, onlay or crown may provide more support. These usually involve two appointments. Ask about the number of visits needed so you can plan the trips from Tillsonburg around work and other commitments.

After replacement

Care routines help new fillings last.

  1. What to expect after treatment

    Mild sensitivity to temperature or biting is common for a short time after replacement. If it persists or the bite feels high, contact the Port Dover office. A quick adjustment may be all that is needed. Avoid chewing on the treated side until the freezing wears off.

  2. Maintaining your new fillings

    Brush twice daily, clean between teeth and limit frequent sugary snacks to protect the edges of new fillings. Regular checkups allow the dentist to monitor them. Coffee, tea and tobacco can stain composite over time, so discuss habits that may help keep fillings looking fresh.

Planning your appointment

Have older fillings checked from Tillsonburg.

Call our Port Dover office to ask about an assessment of your older fillings. Mention any sensitivity, cracks or appearance concerns you have noticed.

If several fillings may need replacing, ask how the work could be sequenced to reduce the number of trips.

Port Dover Family Dentistry

697 Norfolk County Hwy 6, Unit 2, Port Dover, ON N0A 1N2
519-583-2929Directions to our office (opens in a new tab)Office hours & contact details

Before you book

Filling replacement questions

Have a question about your situation? Our team can help you plan a visit.

Should I replace all my old silver fillings?

Not necessarily. Sound fillings that are not causing problems may not need replacing. The dentist will assess each one and explain whether replacement is recommended for health or is a cosmetic choice, since every replacement removes a little more tooth.

Does replacing a filling hurt?

Local anaesthetic is usually used, so you should feel pressure rather than pain. Some sensitivity afterwards is common and usually settles within days or weeks. Tell the team if you have had trouble getting numb before so they can plan.

Will a new tooth-coloured filling match my teeth?

Composite is shade-matched to the surrounding teeth. If you plan to whiten, consider doing so first, as composite does not change colour with whitening and a filling matched beforehand may later look darker.

How long do replacement fillings last?

It depends on the size, material, bite forces and home care. Many last for years. Regular checkups help the dentist monitor the edges and recommend repairs when needed, before decay can spread beneath them.

Can several fillings be replaced in one visit?

Sometimes, depending on the teeth involved and your comfort. Ask the dentist whether grouping replacements is suitable, especially if you want to reduce trips from Tillsonburg. Longer visits are not right for everyone, so comfort matters too.

Recognized year after year

Winner of the Three Best Rated Award

Best Dentists in Norfolk

Proudly recognized among Norfolk’s top-rated dental practices for six consecutive years.

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2021 Excellence award

    2021 Winner

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2022 Excellence award

    2022 Winner

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2023 Excellence award

    2023 Winner

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2024 Excellence award

    2024 Winner

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2025 Excellence award

    2025 Winner

  • Three Best Rated Best Business of 2026 Excellence award

    2026 Winner

Stories from our patients

Comfortable care, shared in their own words.

Watch a patient’s experience and browse more five-star reviews from people who have visited our Port Dover dental clinic.

Patient video

Welcoming and Wonderful Practice

A patient shares the welcoming atmosphere and positive experience they found at our Port Dover office.

Google reviews

More five-star experiences

★★★★★

“I believe it’s been about 7+ years that I have been a patient here, and I have never had an unpleasant experience. Everyone from the…”

★★★★★

“Honestly I’ve been terrified of the dentist since I was super young. So I’ve avoided it most of my life. But I knew I had…”

★★★★★

“I had a really good experience here. The whole team is friendly and makes you feel comfortable right away. The dentist took the time to…”

★★★★★

“I recently visited Port Dover Family Dentistry and had one of the best dental experiences I’ve ever had. The moment I walked in, I noticed…”

G
★★★★★

“I visited Port Dover Family Dentistry for a routine teeth cleaning and a dental filling, and I had a great experience from start to finish.…”

★★★★★

“Let's face it, going to the dentist is probably not at the top of anyone's To Do list! However, visiting Port Dover Dentistry has never…”

★★★★★

“Dr. Syed Bukhari and his staff, they were focused on reducing my anxiety and on making my visits pleasant,, from Dr. S,, with his perfect…”

★★★★★

“I have always had a terrible fear of the dentist. The team here made me feel so comfortable and I was able to get more…”

★★★★★

“The best experience with Dr. Mithwani.. he explained everything in details and helped me understand what I need to do to save my teeth.”

★★★★★

“It was my first time visiting Port Dover Family dentistry. First of all Sylvia was amazing. She made me feel so comfortable. She was so…”

★★★★★

“I recently visited Port Dover Family Dentistry and had an outstanding experience. Dr. Bukhari and his team were professional and respectful. They made me feel…”

★★★★★

“Went to Port Dover Dentistry for an oral exam, a cleaning and some restoration work after not seeing a dentist in quite a while. The…”

Swipe or use the arrows

Read all reviews

Your next visit can start today

Ready for a healthier, more confident smile?

New patients and CDCP patients are welcome. Tell us how we can help and our Port Dover dental team will follow up with you.

Evening appointments Monday and Tuesday

How can we help?

Our Port Dover dental team is here for you.

Ready to book or have a question? Choose the option that works best for you.

For severe trauma, uncontrolled bleeding, or trouble breathing or swallowing, call 911.

Send us a message

We’ll reply during clinic hours.

Please don’t include private health or financial information.